Toilet Paper and Smartphones: A Comparative Analysis of Design and Usability
When you think about it, toilet paper and smartphones might not seem related at all. But there’s a surprising link between them when we consider their design and usability. The debate over the correct way to hang toilet paper – “over” versus “under” – has been a long-standing one, similar to the tech world’s Android versus iOS debate. It’s about personal preference and hygiene. Health experts recommend the “over” position to minimize contact with germs. When toilet paper is hung “under,” it’s more likely to touch the wall and collect bacteria.
Now, focus on smartphones. The design and interface of these devices are carefully engineered to improve the user experience. They are made to be intuitive, efficient, and clean. Think about how often the phone’s screen is wiped compared to how often a toilet paper dispenser is cleaned. The original patent for the toilet paper roll by Seth Wheeler in 1891 showed the roll in the “over” position. This is similar to how the default settings on a smartphone are configured for the best user experience. Just as people have grown accustomed to these default settings for a smooth experience, the intended design for hanging toilet paper in the “over” position should be recognized.
Learning from Tech and How Design Intent Guides User Experience
Designers in the tech industry invest a lot of time to make sure that the user interface is visually pleasing and functional. They know that good design translates to a better user experience. This concept is also true for something as mundane as toilet paper. By choosing the “over” position, the design intent of the original patent is followed. It’s about functionality and reducing germ spread. Dr. Christian Moro from Bond University has noted that the “over” position lessens the risk of contact with contaminated surfaces.
Consider the design of a smartphone screen. Its layout is deliberate, with the most used apps placed where they are easy to reach. This mirrors the “over” position of toilet paper, which is more accessible and hygienic. Just as people rely on the expertise that goes into smartphone interfaces, the health science that advises on the best way to hang toilet paper should be trusted. It’s a decision that affects health and practicality.
Applying Smartphone Lessons to the Toilet Paper Orientation Debate
What lessons can be taken from smartphones to apply to the toilet paper orientation debate? Quite a few, it turns out. The user-friendly design appreciated in phones can inform the way toilet paper is hung. The “over” position is like the intuitive design of a smartphone – it’s meant to simplify and sanitize lives. And just as people adjust to new updates and features on phones, the most hygienic way to hang toilet paper can also be adopted.
There are exceptions, of course. For those with playful cats or small children, the “under” position might prevent a mess. But these are exceptions rather than the rule. For most bathrooms, the “over” position is like using a smartphone as it’s meant to be used – efficiently and with the user’s well-being in mind.
Optimizing Hygiene and Functionality in Bathroom Etiquette
Ultimately, it’s about maximizing hygiene and functionality. Smartphones are chosen for their superior performance and cleanliness, and toilet paper should be thought about in the same way. The “over” position is historically accurate according to Seth Wheeler’s patent; it’s also the sanitary choice. With harmful bacteria like e.coli on bathroom surfaces, hanging toilet paper “over” is a simple method to decrease germ transmission.
Toilet paper comes in different qualities, from 1-ply to more absorbent types. Regardless of the ply, the hanging method affects its function. While some people are turning to alternatives like bidets and wet wipes, toilet paper is still widely used. Cultural norms and personal habits aside, the “over” position is the preferred method for a clean and functional bathroom, similar to how a well-designed smartphone improves our daily routine.
